Advertisement



Industry

October 20, 2014

The Good of Taste Subjectivity

It’s important that we debunk the popular myth that professional coffee cuppers provide some kind of one-size-fits-all rigid 100-point coffee review that is universally accepted by enlightened consumers and coffee professionals alike.

Although cupping is a helpful tool for coffee producers, roasters and retailers to diagnose and understand more about their products, as an industry we must begin to rethink how to use the information it provides more effectively and also how to present it to consumers in a more approachable and meaningful way.
Ask any coffee marketer where cupping scores come from, and you’ll hear grand tales of wise and gifted gustatory wizards slurping away at endless tables of coffee, instantly decoding complex flavour mysteries and assigning precise scores on a neatly organised scale between 1 and 100: 1 being the worst coffee in all of history and 100 the best imaginable in the foreseeable future. In reality, this is all far from true and also far from useful for the coffee consumer.
We each have differing sensitivity to coffee’s component molecules and interpret the electrochemical signals sent to our brains based on our unique personal experiences and biochemistry.  It is not only possible, but rather, likely that no two people sense the aroma and taste of coffee exactly the same way, which significantly complicates the idea of any universal standard for determining the objective meaning of “good.”
Furthermore, the reviews and reviewers themselves warrant some scrutiny. Human beings are notoriously lousy instruments for the objective evaluation of flavour, of which 75% or more is from retronasal aroma. Our tongues are equipped only to sense the five basic taste modalities: sweet, sour, salt, bitter and umami (positive savoury) – possibly fatty, which is presently being debated and may be added to that list soon. Most of coffee’s flavour sensation is detected by the 2,000 or so receptors in our nasal membranes that can distinguish somewhere between 2,000 and 4,000 unique smells. That figure sounds impressive, until you consider that a dog possesses a sense of smell between 10,000 to 100,000 times as acute as a human, meaning that the family pet is a far better coffee taster than you. If only we could teach Fido how to fill out the scoresheet. In the absence of man’s best friend at the cupping table, including any friend or a panel of friends is advisable to capture a broader range of sensory data.
Cupping evaluation systems like those developed by the Specialty Coffee Association of America and used by the Coffee Quality Institute’s Q Grader program are designed to reward the qualities that exemplify what the industry generally agrees to be most valuable and represent ideal characteristics in washed Arabica coffee: the harmonious balance of bright and intense acidity, complex aromas, flavours and mouthfeel, low bitterness and high sweetness. A mathematical 100-point scoring system is universally comfortable and easily communicated among different cultures, so scoresheets are designed, sometimes contorted to fit within that measure.  Some delightful coffees processed by other methods, for example dry natural-processed or Indonesian wet-hulled coffees, are either shoehorned into the same narrow definition of quality, or overlooked entirely. The same was true for the entire species of Robusta coffees, until recently given their own quality differentiation system and specialty scoresheet created in a coordinated Fine Robusta effort led by the Uganda Coffee Development Authority.
Although useful for an internal evaluation of coffee and discussion among the supply chain, industry quality ratings and our arcane lexicon of cupping sensory terms are of little value to consumers: at best, pushing them in the direction of coffees that they may not like and worst, patronising or belittling their opinions. What the specialty coffee industry believes to be good isn’t necessarily what people like, and any heavy-handed attempt to tell them otherwise is perceived as coffee snobbery (if you can’t taste the difference or otherwise disagree with us, you’re clearly unsophisticated).
The situation, however, is not as bleak as it may seem. Knowing that we are faced with the shortcomings of a limited set of protocols and a widely diverse range of consumer tastes, we can all be flexible to apply subjectivity to reviews so that they relate better to consumers and recognise that every coffee has a buyer.
Choice is key among consumers in the age of specialty foods, so coffee cupping and other tools can provide information to help guide consumers to products they will personally value most, regardless of which may be preferred by the so-called learned masters. Recognition of flavour profiles other than those preferred by coffee insiders and validation of consumers’ taste preferences will help specialty coffee expand from an exclusionary club of elite enthusiasts to serve a much larger mass audience of customers than it does today. We must shift from today’s, “We know what’s good and will tell you why,” to, “Here is the information you need to select what you enjoy”.
The consumer statement, “This coffee is delicious,” should be the ultimate goal of every coffee grower, every roaster and retail café, regardless of what is tabulated on any scoresheet. After all, “specialty” is not strictly a quality designation; it’s a differentiation or statement of unique value. There is nothing more valuable to business and the long-term success of an industry than an informed and happy customer. Look for a new coffee evaluation service coming to Café Culture Magazine this year that is designed to provide professionals with the traditional laboratory information that they need and consumers with the information that they want to make an informed purchase decision.

Written by Andrew Hetzel
CONTACT  
Cafe Culture International   T.  (02) 6583 7163
W. www.cafeculture.com/education





MPM Advertisment
 
 

 

Smartpay

p: 1800 959 680 e: sales@smartpay.com.au w: www.smartpay.com.au f: @SmartpayAustralia Smartpay offer simple and secure Eftpos solutions and merchant services, tailored to meet your business needs. Locally owned and operated wit...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The Salad Servers

p: 02 9417 7958 e: info@saladervers.com.au w: www.saladservers.com.au The Salad Servers have been the experts & innovators in providing gourmet salads and meal solutions of unsurpassed quality since 1979. Including salads (...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Purezza

p. 1300 792 673 e: sales@purezza.com.au w: www.purezza.com.au   Purezza is reforming the hospitality industry with a product that offers various benefits from increasing profits to reducing carbon footprint. The Purezza system...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Abrisca Roasters of Coffee

p. (07) 3217 3316 p. (07) 3393 1215 e. sales@abrisca.com e. sales@koffeetek.com w. www.abrisca.com Abrisca Roasters are a family owned and operated Brisbane Roastery who specialise in blending high quality beans from all over t...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
Advertisement
 

Serious Smoothies

1800 260 884 f: @SeriousSmoothiesAuNZ w. www.serioussmoothies.com.au Recognising the demand from foodservice providers for convenient all natural smoothies, Serious Smoothies developed a range of frozen, pre-portioned smoothie ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Tavalon

p. 1800 241 103 e. wholesale@tavalon.com.au w. www.tavalon.com.au f. @tavalonaus i. #tavalonaus“More than just a beverage to consume, but a story to tell, a memory to share, a moment to revel in” Tavalon specialises...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The Paper Cup Company

p: 0393351528 e: orders@tpccau.com w: www.tpccau.com YouTube Proudly Australian made. Largest range of paper cups. Smallest Minimum Order Quantities. TPCC is a fully Australian family owned company, employing over 25 staff at o...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Blynzz Coffee

p: 0412690478 e: info@blynzzcoffee.com.au w: www.blynzzcoffee.com.au f: @Blynzz-Coffee-Roaster i: #blynzzcoffee Blynzz is a small batch custom coffee roaster who has a proven tracked record of producing coffee of exceptional st...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Nestlé Professional

p. 1800 20 30 50 e. CustomerService.NestleProfessional@au.nestle.com w. www.nestleprofessional.com.au Nestlé Professional is your trusted partner in Foodservice, we deliver high quality branded and customised solutions. Our kn...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Freudenberg Home and Cleaning Solutions

p: 1300669686 e: customerservice@oates.com.au w: www.oates.com.au/home.aspx f: @OatesCleansBest i: #oatescleansbest Freudenberg Home and Cleaning Solutions (FHCS) is a leading international company for branded cleaning products...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Calming the storm in a teacup

A gift of the GABA GABA tea has been around since the 1980s but is only just starting to gain more traction with western tea drinkers for its health properties. Here’s an overview of what it is, by Adeline Teoh. Tea and f...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Feed hungry kids—swap cereal for coffee

One in five Australian kids go to school hungry. Our mission is to change this statistic—one nutritious breakfast at a time. Kids who start their school day hungry are likely to lose more than two hours of essential learning ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Muffin Break’s Commitment to the War on Waste

Muffin Break, a coffee and bakery franchise, has also made their commitment to reduce their impact in the environment. Kicking off this August, Muffin Break: Partners with Simply Cups to recycle 11 million cups Partners with Re...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

How Improved Efficiency Translates into Increased Profit for Your Café

There is little doubt that in the current challenging economic climate, every dollar counts in the pursuit of business success. This is particularly the case in the hospitality sector. The money that small businesses such as ca...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Tea Drop

p: 0393832300 e: sales@teadrop.com.au w: www.teadrop.com.au f: @TeaDropTea i: #teadroptea We are a specialist tea house that has been brewing and creating blends by sourcing leaves harvested from around the world since our ince...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Cafe Culture Digital Issue 6 – Now available

Latest news, trends, products and reviews – every month.       THIS MONTH FEATURES: – The Grounds discuss setting up your coffee for success – Puqpress pre-launch limited offer – Uniwell&#...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Minas Hill Coffee

p: 03 9378 80 90  0402083237 e: marcelo@minashill.com.au w: http://www.minashill.com.au f: @minashillcoffee i: #minas_hill_coffee Passion and commitment, transparency and sustainability. Minas Hill Coffee is a Brazilian green ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

How to Create an Effective Customer Loyalty Program for your Café

Customer loyalty has long been the ‘holy grail’ of hospitality. The old saying is true – it really is easier to keep a customer than to find a new one. And for years, café operators have striven to unlock the potential o...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

THE COFFEE CLUB FURTHER REWARDS COFFEE DRINKERS FOR TAKING A STAND AGAINST WASTE

The Coffee Club has this week announced a nationwide franchisee commitment to offer a 50-cent discount on hot beverage purchases when customers bring their own re-usable cups into The Coffee Club. The discount, offered in all T...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Milkadamia responds to FDA crackdown on ‘milk’ term for plant products

‘Moo is Moot’ but macadamia milk producer prepared for crackdown Even the nut-based milk market is getting crowded with at least a handful of nut options available for consumers: almond — the nut market leader, ha...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

THE WTBC CHAMPIONSHIPS RETURN TO FINE FOOD AUSTRALIA

This will be the third year the WTBC (World Tea Brewers Championship) takes center stage at Fine food Australia, where the best tea-ristas will come together and compete over 2 days to vie for the 2018 Australian WTBC Champions...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Bygreen

p: +61738880566 e: sales@bygreen.com.au w: www.bygreen.com.au f: @bygreen.au i: #bygreen.au Bygreen is a family owned Australian business manufacturing and importing a range of Food Packaging products sold trough distributors a...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Almond Breeze Wants to Make You #Instafamous

Sydney, Australia, 19 July 2018: Almond Breeze, the world’s leading almond milk brand, is celebrating the mouth-watering creations made by its social media fans by featuring the tastiest in its new advertising campaign. A min...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

5 simple ways to protect your business from scammers this tax time

The end of the financial year isn’t just a busy time for businesses – it’s also a prime time for cybercriminals who try to steal your information and money. It’s a good time to stop and remind your employees of the ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Givex

p: 61 7 5322 5360 e: sean.brandon@givex.com w: www.givex.com f: @GivexCorporation Givex offers omnichannel POS, gift card, loyalty and stored value ticketing solutions which drive sales for our clients, help them better underst...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Honest to Goodness

p: 02 8310 1800 e: info@goodness.com.au w: www.goodness.com.au f: @organicfoodsydney i: #teamgoodness Honest to Goodness is a leading Australian supplier of certified organic wholefoods & natural products. Our extensive ran...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Skip

p: 1800 001 852 e: support@skip.com.au w: www.skip.com.au/venues f: @SkipApp i: #skipapp Skip – the smarter way to offer online pre-order, cashless payment and loyalty. Skip is the app that allows customers to skip the qu...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Introductory Espresso Machine Technician Course – July 25-26

Do you have a handy team member in your coffee business that is repairing your espresso equipment but needs some assistance in understanding the technical side of being a coffee technician? This two-day course is designed for n...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Sanremo Australia

p: 02 9898 2200 e: info@sanremoaustralia.com.au w: http://www.sanremoaustralia.com.au f: @SanremoCoffeeMachinesAustralia i: @sanremoaustralia Sanremo Australia is relatively young company driven by a team of dedicated professio...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

REDCAT

p: 1300473322 e: hello@redcat.com.au w: www2.redcat.com.au/cafes f: @RedcatPOS i: #RedcatPOS Hospitality software, by hospitality people, for your hospitality business. Redcat provides a locally developed and supported, integra...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Golden Bean pioneering the competition space

It was just over ten years ago that I had a vision as to how we could showcase the hidden heroes of the coffee world. The Coffee Roaster was the little gem working at the back end of the business, developing the product that ma...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

KEVIN BACON’S RETIRING!

It’s been a roller coaster and wonderful ride with Kev, who’s been a star of The Grounds for over 5 years now and we’d like to honour the big guy with 7 Weeks of Kevin – a celebration of all he’s given to The Grounds ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The Health Nutt

t: 1300 557848 e: info@thehealthnutt.com.au w: thehealthnutt.com.au f: @thehealthnutt1 i: #thehealthnutt The famous Protein Balls, Raw Slices and What The Fudge by The Health Nutt – Sydney’s leading cafe supplier for ra...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Coffee drinkers may live longer

For people who love a morning cup of coffee, and a few more cups throughout the day, there is good news. Coffee drinkers may live longer, according to a new study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JA...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

New minimum wage takes effect

The Fair Work Ombudsman is calling on businesses to check the new minimum pay rates that apply ahead of a new national minimum wage coming into effect from the first pay period on or after Sunday, 1 July 2018. From this date, t...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Registering a business just got easier

Use the Business Registration Service to help you get your business up and running.     Are you looking at registering a business? The Business Registration Service makes it easy to apply for key business and tax regi...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Cafe Culture Digital Issue 5 – Now available

Latest news, trends, products and reviews – every month.       THIS MONTHS FEATURES: – The Grounds discuss the value of baristas – Mixing with the best – with Alchemy – Uniwell’...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

NEW APP GIVES FARMERS REAL-TIME GRAIN OF TRUTH

For the first time, Australian farmers can forecast grain yield at the touch of a button, thanks to a new smart phone app developed by Australia’s national science agency, CSIRO. The innovation, known as ‘Graincast&...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

DINING A TOP PRIORITY FOR DOMESTIC TOURISTS

Data from the most recent National Visitor Survey (NVS) released today has shown an increase in domestic tourists’ overnight spend on restaurant and takeaway meals, both in terms of the dollar amount and as a proportion of ov...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Don’t pay for government grant information

Watch out for government grant scams… Last updated: 27 June 2018 Are you looking for a government grant to help fund your business? Don’t get caught out by scams and paying for access to government grant information. Go...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Buhler

p: +61 (0) 3 9872 7900 e: buhler.melbourne@buhlergroup.com w: www.buhlergroup.com f: www.facebook.com/buhlergroup Bühler is setting worldwide standards in the production of coffee machinery. Product quality, process efficiency...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Harney Teas

t: 03 9099 0293 e: Info@Harneyteas.com.au w: www.harneyteas.com.au/ f: @harneyandsonsaustralasia/ i: #harneyandsons_australasia/ Harney and Sons luxury tea have a wide range of wholesale products that include the traditional to...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Essential Coffee

t. 1300 324 111 e. info@ebg.com.au w. www.essentialcoffee.com.au Essential Coffee provides managed coffee solutions to thousands of businesses across Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, The Middle East and United Kingdom. ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Essential Coffee

t. 1300 324 111 e. info@ebg.com.au w. www.essentialcoffee.com.au Essential Coffee provides managed coffee solutions to thousands of businesses across Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, The Middle East and United Kingdom. ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Milkadamia – macadamia milk:

w. www.milkadamia.com.au e. enquiries@milkadamia.com.au f. facebook.com/milkadamiaau i. Insta – @milkadamiaau Milkadamia is a family owned, vertically integrated human sized macadamia endeavour. Because our family grows t...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Assisting students with special behavioural needs.

  Café Culture recently was asked to assist in setting up a practice café at the Naremburn School. This kitchen project is being run by 2016 Master Chef Australia session eight winner, Elena Duggan, and is aimed at assis...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Artisti Coffee Roasters

E: info@artisti.com.au P: 66 53 1182 W: www.artisti.com.au Insta: #artisticoffeeroasters FB: @artisticoffee Address: Unit 3/11 craft Close, Toormina. NSW 2452 Living and breathing coffee with 24/7 good coffee vibes! Yes, of cou...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Start your business off on the right foot!

Don’t start a business in Australia without using business.gov.au’s new Starting a Business Guide!   Thinking of starting a business? Or maybe you’re in the early phases of operating? Setting up your own business is exci...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 




ad