Advertisement



Industry

June 9, 2012

Discovering the true nature of sugar

While coffee roasters and café owners alike probably wish their coffee was appreciated by customers without sugar, the reality is that the majority of consumers add sweeteners to their coffee. However, few coffee roasters and baristas have tested the effect that sugar has on their coffee blend.

Most who have are quite startled to find out what their typical customer is tasting, despite the numerous hours spent in perfecting a coffee blend or learning to extract the perfect espresso. Increasingly however, it seems cafes are becoming aware of this, if the growing number of cafes adorning their tables with a rich golden sweet powder called Panela is any indication.Seeing this trend, I decided to jump on a plane to visit the state of Santander in Colombia. This region is typically known for coffee production, but also has a reputation for producing high quality organic Panela. I hoped to learn how Panela was grown, what affected its quality and why Panela was becoming the preferred sweetener for coffee amongst leading cafes. What was it about Panela that gave it a smooth, non-acidic sweetness that maintained the balance of a coffee blend, where others sugars had a negative effect? How did Panela differ to the sugars I had been used to?All these questions and more would be answered when I arrived at a Panela farm in a sleepy little farming town called Chitarake. My tour began with a visit to the office, where I met the farm’s caretaker. On our walk to the cane fields, I was shown the farm’s composting area, where organic fertilizers where made using manure collected from animals on the farm and part of the waste sugar cane left over after production. The rich compost provided ample nutrients, as well as helping to maintain the right pH levels in the soil for the cane to grow. The farmer explained that it was critical that the right nourishment be given to the soil to enable the fast growth of the cane over the long term.In a general sense, Panela is quite easy to grow; however, there are many factors that affect its quality. To establish new cane fields, short lengths of sugar cane from seed plants are placed in trenches spaced 1.2 meters apart. If the conditions are right, new cane will germinate. The cane grows quite quickly, producing 5 annual harvests before it has to be removed and the field replanted. The soil in which the cane grows is closely monitored, with the farm’s caretaker adding calcium to the soil to manage the level of acidity to optimum levels. The rich soil, combined with the natural climatic variation in temperature, helps to develop complexity and character in the flavour of the cane.

Harvesting the cane is a labour intensive but simple process. The cane is cut with a machete close to the base of the plant, then stripped of its leaves. The leaves are left to decompose on the field once removed from the cane, providing protection and nutrients for the soil. The stripped cane is then bundled and placed on horseback, where it is carried back to the factory ready for processing. While observing this process, I was fortunate to be able to taste sugar juice directly form the cane – it was amazing how flavoursome and moreish the juice was, without being sickly sweet – paired with a pleasurable energetic lift.

The process of extracting the juice from the cane and turning it into powder is also a labour intensive but simple process. The sugar cane is crushed to extract the juice, a sweet pale green liquid that is then passed through a filter, where large impurities are removed. The juice is then transferred through a series of heating vats, where the temperature is slowly increased. In the first vat, the resin from the bark of a local tree is added to the juice, which coagulates the impurities and brings them to the surface. The scum that forms is then skimmed from the surface, then the juice is transferred to the next vat, where it is heated further. Calcium is then added to neutralize the acidity of the juice; it is passed through strainers into hotter vats, where the moisture is further removed, leaving a thick, bubbling syrup.

The hot syrup is then left to cool, where it crystalizes into powdery clumps of Panela. The Panela is then sieved to create a coarse and fluffy golden powder. The dried Panela can then be placed into cubes, sachets, or even flavoured. The moisture content of the Panela is then sometimes further reduced, to create a more intense caramelized flavour, by baking the granulated Panela in ovens. The Panela is then packaged into bulk bags and made ready for transport.

I was quite taken back by how simple and raw the whole process was. It wasn’t until I studied how white sugar and raw sugar was made that I began to understand why Panela tasted so different. Panela is simply the powder that is left when whole sugar cane juice is evaporated. Much of the nutrients, impurities and flavour of the sugar cane is preserved. Perhaps for this reason, Panela is considered more than just a sweetener, but a drink in its own right in Colombia. Aqua Panela is a very popular drink, made by dissolving a cube of Panela in hot water and adding a squeeze of lime. The beverage is considered quite wholesome and nutritious.

Soon after my return to Australia, I was fortunate to have a chance meeting with an engineer who had worked for a large sugar refining company in New Zealand. I shared what I had discovered from my visit, and he explained that the process of making refined sugar was quite sophisticated. He explained that the fine crystallization that can be observed with refined sugar was only possible through the removal of impurities.

The process for making raw sugar begins in a similar process to Panela, with the cane being harvested and crushed to extract the cane juice. Calcium hydroxide and carbon dioxide are added to clarify the juice, by creating insoluble calcium compounds. The calcium hydroxide also raises the juice’s pH. With the addition of poly acrylamides, the impurities are filtered from the juice. The juice is then treated with activated carbon and sent through an evaporator to remove water and causing the juice to thicken. The juice is heated in a vacuum, and fine seed crystals are added to aid in the formation of sugar crystals. The mother liquor is separated from the sugar crystals, which is then made into molasses, and a centrifuge is used to obtain raw sugar.

To make white sugar, the raw sugar is then melted down again through a process called affination, that dissolves the remaining molasses. The sugar is then washed, clarified and de-coloured using phosphoric acid and calcium hydroxide or with calcium dioxide. The final stage is to boil the solution one last time to concentrate it into white granulated sugar crystals.

So now I understood why Panela had a less acidic sweetness than raw and white sugar, but I still didn’t understand why when I had compared white and raw sugar in an espresso with Panela, the flavour balance of the espresso containing refined sugar seemed to deteriorate more the longer that it was left to sit. Panela seemed to maintain the overall balance of the coffee blend and sometimes enhance it. The sharp sweetness of refined sugar seemed also to diminish the complexity of the coffee it is placed in.

To be honest, I believe further investigation is required to find the cause of these changes, probably with the assistance of a food chemist who can identify the chemical reactions taking place in the coffee. I suspect that a chemical or additive used in refining is reacting negatively with the coffee, as there is often a synthetic flavour that can be observed. That said, I noticed similar but less pronounced changes even with organic raw sugar. It has also been suggested to me that the anti caking agents often blended with the sugar to preserve the free-flowing nature of refined sugar could be a contributing factor.

Whatever the cause, I encourage you to experiment with different sugars in your café or coffee roastery, to see how the sweetener affects the balance and flavour of your coffee. Choose one that best complements and maintains the balance of your blend and improves the overall appeal of your coffee. Common sense suggests that it is the last impression associated with the final sip that will be a deciding factor in whether the customer will purchase a second cup of coffee. So why not conduct your own experiment now?

To compare the effect of different sugars on your coffee, I recommend that you use the following method:

1. Make 4 espressos, and in each one place a different sweetener (artificial sweetener, white sugar, raw sugar and panela).
2. Stir the sweetener in and take a small sip; pay attention to the tactile and flavour balance. Give the coffee a rating and record your comments.
3. Wait 40 seconds, then take a second sip. Again, make some comments about the tactile and flavour balance of the coffee and give the coffee a rating.

What did you find? I will be keen to hear about your findings! Email me at nwakeford@somage.com.au If you are interested to learn more, you can find a video of Panela production in Colombia at www.somage.tv.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Nathan Wakeford is the Managing Director of Somage Fine Foods, a company committed to pioneering improved product quality and knowledge in foodservice venues. Nathan has been a previous Chair of the Victorian Chapter of AASCA, a sensory judge and barista championship competitor. Nathan is also a founder of the Specialty Tea Association of Australia and a regular contributor to industry publications and media supporting the hospitality industry.

[nggallery id=36]




MPM Advertisment
 
 

 

Austraw

p: +61738880566 e: sales@austraw.com.au w: www.austraw.com.au f: @austraw.au i: #austraw.au Austraw P/L soon to be trading as Bygreen, is a family owned Australian business manufacturing and importing a range of Food Packaging ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Almond Breeze Wants to Make You #Instafamous

Sydney, Australia, 19 July 2018: Almond Breeze, the world’s leading almond milk brand, is celebrating the mouth-watering creations made by its social media fans by featuring the tastiest in its new advertising campaign. A min...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

5 simple ways to protect your business from scammers this tax time

The end of the financial year isn’t just a busy time for businesses – it’s also a prime time for cybercriminals who try to steal your information and money. It’s a good time to stop and remind your employees of the ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Givex

p: 61 7 5322 5360 e: sean.brandon@givex.com w: www.givex.com f: @GivexCorporation Givex offers omnichannel POS, gift card, loyalty and stored value ticketing solutions which drive sales for our clients, help them better underst...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
Advertisement
 

Honest to Goodness

p: 02 8310 1800 e: info@goodness.com.au w: www.goodness.com.au f: @organicfoodsydney i: #teamgoodness Honest to Goodness is a leading Australian supplier of certified organic wholefoods & natural products. Our extensive ran...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Skip

p: 1800 001 852 e: support@skip.com.au w: www.skip.com.au/venues f: @SkipApp i: #skipapp Skip – the smarter way to offer online pre-order, cashless payment and loyalty. Skip is the app that allows customers to skip the qu...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Introductory Espresso Machine Technician Course – July 25-26

Do you have a handy team member in your coffee business that is repairing your espresso equipment but needs some assistance in understanding the technical side of being a coffee technician? This two-day course is designed for n...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Sanremo Australia

p: 02 9898 2200 e: info@sanremoaustralia.com.au w: http://www.sanremoaustralia.com.au f: @SanremoCoffeeMachinesAustralia i: #sanremoaustralia Sanremo Australia is relatively young company driven by a team of dedicated professio...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

REDCAT

p: 1300473322 e: hello@redcat.com.au w: www2.redcat.com.au/cafes f: @RedcatPOS i: #RedcatPOS Hospitality software, by hospitality people, for your hospitality business. Redcat provides a locally developed and supported, integra...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Golden Bean pioneering the competition space

It was just over ten years ago that I had a vision as to how we could showcase the hidden heroes of the coffee world. The Coffee Roaster was the little gem working at the back end of the business, developing the product that ma...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

KEVIN BACON’S RETIRING!

It’s been a roller coaster and wonderful ride with Kev, who’s been a star of The Grounds for over 5 years now and we’d like to honour the big guy with 7 Weeks of Kevin – a celebration of all he’s given to The Grounds ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The Health Nutt

t: 1300 557848 e: info@thehealthnutt.com.au w: thehealthnutt.com.au f: @thehealthnutt1 i: #thehealthnutt The famous Protein Balls, Raw Slices and What The Fudge by The Health Nutt – Sydney’s leading cafe supplier for ra...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Coffee drinkers may live longer

For people who love a morning cup of coffee, and a few more cups throughout the day, there is good news. Coffee drinkers may live longer, according to a new study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JA...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

New minimum wage takes effect

The Fair Work Ombudsman is calling on businesses to check the new minimum pay rates that apply ahead of a new national minimum wage coming into effect from the first pay period on or after Sunday, 1 July 2018. From this date, t...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Registering a business just got easier

Use the Business Registration Service to help you get your business up and running.     Are you looking at registering a business? The Business Registration Service makes it easy to apply for key business and tax regi...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Cafe Culture Digital Issue 5 – Now available

Latest news, trends, products and reviews – every month.       THIS MONTHS FEATURES: – The Grounds discuss the value of baristas – Mixing with the best – with Alchemy – Uniwell’...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

NEW APP GIVES FARMERS REAL-TIME GRAIN OF TRUTH

For the first time, Australian farmers can forecast grain yield at the touch of a button, thanks to a new smart phone app developed by Australia’s national science agency, CSIRO. The innovation, known as ‘Graincast&...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

DINING A TOP PRIORITY FOR DOMESTIC TOURISTS

Data from the most recent National Visitor Survey (NVS) released today has shown an increase in domestic tourists’ overnight spend on restaurant and takeaway meals, both in terms of the dollar amount and as a proportion of ov...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Don’t pay for government grant information

Watch out for government grant scams… Last updated: 27 June 2018 Are you looking for a government grant to help fund your business? Don’t get caught out by scams and paying for access to government grant information. Go...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Buhler

p: +61 (0) 3 9872 7900 e: buhler.melbourne@buhlergroup.com w: www.buhlergroup.com f: www.facebook.com/buhlergroup Bühler is setting worldwide standards in the production of coffee machinery. Product quality, process efficiency...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Harney Teas

t: 03 9099 0293 e: Info@Harneyteas.com.au w: www.harneyteas.com.au/ f: @harneyandsonsaustralasia/ i: #harneyandsons_australasia/ Harney and Sons luxury tea have a wide range of wholesale products that include the traditional to...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Essential Coffee

t. 1300 324 111 e. info@ebg.com.au w. www.essentialcoffee.com.au Essential Coffee provides managed coffee solutions to thousands of businesses across Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, The Middle East and United Kingdom. ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Essential Coffee

t. 1300 324 111 e. info@ebg.com.au w. www.essentialcoffee.com.au Essential Coffee provides managed coffee solutions to thousands of businesses across Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, The Middle East and United Kingdom. ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Milkadamia – macadamia milk:

w. www.milkadamia.com.au e. enquiries@milkadamia.com.au f. facebook.com/milkadamiaau i. Insta – @milkadamiaau Milkadamia is a family owned, vertically integrated human sized macadamia endeavour. Because our family grows t...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Assisting students with special behavioural needs.

  Café Culture recently was asked to assist in setting up a practice café at the Naremburn School. This kitchen project is being run by 2016 Master Chef Australia session eight winner, Elena Duggan, and is aimed at assis...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Artisti Coffee Roasters

E: info@artisti.com.au P: 66 53 1182 W: www.artisti.com.au Insta: #artisticoffeeroasters FB: @artisticoffee Address: Unit 3/11 craft Close, Toormina. NSW 2452 Living and breathing coffee with 24/7 good coffee vibes! Yes, of cou...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Start your business off on the right foot!

Don’t start a business in Australia without using business.gov.au’s new Starting a Business Guide!   Thinking of starting a business? Or maybe you’re in the early phases of operating? Setting up your own business is exci...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The Gig Economy: Navigating new ways to work

It’s Friday night and it has been a long week.  The fridge is as depleted as you are and the mob needs feeding. But that’s okay, because there are endless choices for dinner and several ways in which it can be delivered to...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

R&CA WELCOMES PAYROLL TAX AND TRAINING INITIATIVES IN NSW BUDGET

Restaurant & Catering Australia (R&CA) has welcomed initiatives aimed at reducing the cost of doing business as well as expanding the accessibility of apprenticeships throughout NSW unveiled as part of today’s 2018 &#...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Is your tax practitioner registered?

A reminder for all small business owners.   The Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) is reminding all small business owners to check their tax agents, BAS agents or tax (financial) advisers are registered with the TPB, if you use one...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

TOURISM AND SMALL BUSINESS WINNERS IN QUEENSLAND’S 2018 – 19 BUDGET

Restaurant & Catering Australia (R&CA)  has welcomed the Queensland Government’s  budget measures to support the State’s tourism and small business  sectors  as outlined in  its  2018 – 19 State  Budget...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Cultured Products: Riverina Fresh

P. 1800 993 081 E. consumer.relations@riverinafresh.com.au W. www.riverinafresh.com.au FB. www.facebook.com/riverinafresh I. www.instagram.com/riverinafresh At Riverina Fresh, we’re proudly Australian owned and sourced exclus...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

HELP NEEDED FOR VICTIMS OF GUATEMALAN DISASTER

You’re invited to help with the funeral expenses at the Santa Clara Dry Mill in Antigua where workers died in the recent volcanic eruption in Guatemala. And with medical expenses of local children who’ve suffered massive bu...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Our thoughts are with Guatemala

Our thoughts are with Guatemala and it’s people, and with our coffee friends, during this time of hardship. These photos were sent to us from our friends at Terra Negra Trade  and show the force of the volcanic eruption...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

What is a Broccoli Latte?

The product, developed by Hort Innovation and CSIRO, Australia’s national science agency, packs a healthy punch with approximately one serve of broccoli in every two tablespoons of powder. A Melbourne café became the fir...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Rubia Coffee Traders Vertical Gravity Fed Destoner

The aim of the Vertical Gravity Fed Destoner is to separate foreign heavy materials encountered in roasted coffee seeds. The design of this system is based on the principle that roasted coffee seeds are lighter than the mass we...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Changes are coming to GST

Make sure your business is ready from 1 July 2018. Last updated: 30 May 2018 From 1 July 2018, the goods and services tax (GST) will apply to retail sales of low value physical goods ($1000 or less) that have been imported to A...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

ACT’S ONE – STOP CAFÉ PROGRAM TO CUT THROUGH RED TAPE BURDEN

Restaurant & Catering Australia (R&CA) has welcomed the AC T Government’s new One Stop Café program, as announced in the 2018 – 19 Territory Budget. Under the program, café – owners will be able to acces...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The WTBC experience with Tania Stacey

WTBC experience – Tania Stacey The opportunity to participate in the Shanghai WTBC was an experience that helped to build on my knowledge of the modern tea world.  It is a competition platform that suits competitors from...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Countrywide Café of the Year – Winners

In February this year, Countrywide, Australia’s largest Food Service Distributor Group, launched a brand new promotion, ‘Countrywide Café of the Year’. The competition created quite a buzz across the nation, giving away ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Cafe Culture Digital Issue 4 – now available!

Latest news, trends, products and reviews – every month. THIS MONTH FEATURES: – Insights to what shapes your industry report – Styling with The Grounds – Politics, logistics and direct trade with Phil Di...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

2018 Speciality Tea Awards

Royal Hobart Fine Foods has opened up to the blossoming Australian specialty tea industry and created 15 categories which will be awarded Gold, Silver & Bronze Metals n the 29thof July.   entries.hobartshowground.com.a...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Barista Supplies

Proudly designed and made in Australia, the Temptag milk thermometer sticker gives baristas greater control when steaming milk. An important part of serving a great coffee is the consistency in milk temperature. The patented Te...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

2018 Breezey Masters Latte Art Competition enjoys a wildly successful 2nd heat in Perth

The WA heat for Breezey Masters 2018 made for an intense spectacle on the evening of May 30th. Once again we had a fantastic turnout of 20 competitors fighting for their place in November’s Melbourne Grand Final. We were extr...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Brazil to host coffee world championships for the first time

In November, the International Coffee Week will host 4 international championships with competitors of over 40 nationalities and thousands of visitors The World Cup of Coffee with its various categories is happening, and it wil...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

The battle for Australia’s best brew heats up

The claim of Australia’s coffee capital is officially up for grabs, as international travel authority Lonely Planet publishes its Global Coffee Tour this month. Melbourne has the famed reputation for Australia’s best coffee...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 

 

Cafe Culture Digital Issue 3

Cafe Culture Digital Cafe Culture Digital Issue 3 – Reusable cup feature  
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Cultured Products – DaVinci Gourmet

DaVinci Gourmet, The Story of Flavour Genius. We believe that Baristas and Mixologists are creative and that they seek perfection to amaze their audiences. We are the contemporary choice for professional drink makers inspired b...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 
 

Coffee Waste Is Now Fetching a 480% Premium Over Coffee Itself

“Aida Batlle grows coffee on her family’s farm in the hills surrounding El Salvador’s Santa Ana Volcano. Like generations before her, she had little use for the skin that encases the beans, so she’d turn it into ...
by Cafe Culture Mag
 

 




ad