June 21, 2018

The Gig Economy: Navigating new ways to work

It’s Friday night and it has been a long week.  The fridge is as depleted as you are and the mob needs feeding. But that’s okay, because there are endless choices for dinner and several ways in which it can be delivered to your front door.

Home delivery is not new in Australia. But the gig economy has offered up many more opportunities for consumers, workers and businesses across a number of fronts, not just your dinner table.

New technologies and platforms offering peer-to-peer marketplaces for jobs and services have had high uptake and have quickly become established in the labour market and in our lives. In doing so, they have been variously welcomed as an opportunity for entrepreneurialism or derided as a source of exploitation.

Consumers have more options than ever before, get a wardrobe moved, fence fixed, or need a ride home. Businesses can seemingly expand their customer base without significant investment so long as they have an internet connection.  If the business can get the logistics right, it can scale up.

For workers, the new tech platforms may offer flexibility and choice: to work when they want, or earn some extra cash, on top of other jobs or when they are between jobs.

But it may be unclear whether such workers are covered by the protections contained in the Fair Work Act. Many of the new models treat these workers as independent contractors rather than employees. Questions arise as to whether these workers are genuinely contractors who are running their own business, or whether they are employees who are entitled to receive protections such as minimum rates of pay, paid leave, superannuation and workers compensation.

As the Fair Work Ombudsman, it is not my intention to pass value judgments on the nature of business operations, or to stifle innovation. I am not seeking to deny anyone’s opportunities. But my job is to ensure compliance with the law in an age of disruption. Where employees are incorrectly classified as independent contractors, it has the potential to not only affect the worker but also unfairly disadvantage other businesses applying award rates of pay and conditions. Disruption of existing markets is only legitimate if it is lawful.

This is particularly important given our experience that the most vulnerable workers often end up in the most exploitative scenarios. In the last five years, the Fair Work Ombudsman has taken twenty cases to court alleging sham contracting, usually with respect to low skilled workers such as cleaners, retail assistance and couriers.

Pondering the question of how these new models intersect with the law is therefore more than just an academic exercise – the answer has real world impact on real, often vulnerable, people. And while there has been much theorising, to date there hasn’t been much by way of decisions in relating to gig economy businesses.

As is appropriate, the Fair Work Ombudsman similarly seeks to apply the law under the current statutory framework with respect to all businesses, irrespective of whether they are emerging or well established.

It is my role to bring public interest matters before the courts and provide certainty to the community. We have just last month seen the Court impose penalties in our first race discrimination case taken under the Fair Work Act involving visa workers treated differently from the rest of a hotel’s workforce. In another first, we have also seen a court impose criminal sanctions for contempt of court against an employer who had, the court found, breached freezing orders the Fair Work Ombudsman had obtained to preserve the assets of a business that had not back paid workers in spite of court orders. The employer’s appeal of this matter will be heard by a Full Bench of the Federal Court and the outcome will be closely watched.

The proceeding we have commenced this week in the Federal Court against food delivery company Foodora is based upon our allegation that three delivery workers were in fact employees, not independent contractors, and thus entitled to the benefits of the Fast Food Award.

When it comes to assessing these new work arrangements courts will assess each situation holistically, in line with the well-established test for determining whether an employment relationship exists. My inspectors do this, and will continue to do this, on a day-to-day basis, but only a court can make a final determination.

While there is a huge attraction to the services offered by the gig economy, the entities offering those services cannot ignore the longstanding law. In seeking the Court’s determination of this issue, we hope to bring greater clarity to the legitimacy and sustainability of the arrangements under which those workers delivering these services are operating.

by Natalie James, Fair Work Ombudsman

(This opinion piece was first published in The Australian on 20 June, 2018)

original article:

MPM Advertisment


Coffee Enthusiasts, Meet Your New Inner West Utopia

Located in the hip, leafy suburb of Alexandria, newly opened specialty coffee bar and café, Went to See the Gypsy (WTSTG) is a clear example for why the Sydney coffee scene is a contender for one of the most advanced in the wo...
by Cafe Culture Mag


Feed hungry kids – swap cereal for coffee

One in five Australian kids go to school hungry¬. Our mission is to change this statistic—one nutritious breakfast at a time.  Kids who start their school day hungry are likely to lose more than two hours of essential learn...
by Cafe Culture Mag



Sydney, Australia, 11th February 2019: Almond Breeze Barista Blend, Australia’s low sugar cafe almond milk, specifically for baristas is proud to be behind the launch of the first National Barista Day.&nbs...
by Cafe Culture Mag


by Cafe Culture Mag


Wolfpack Set To Bring The Community Closer

These days, a cafe needs to have something special to stand out from the pack. And Wolfpack coffee is certainly on to something. Their high quality, specialty roasted coffee selection has something for everyone, but it’s the ...
by Cafe Culture Mag



China Cafe Study Tour 2019

Attend the #1 Largest China Cafe Expo Cafe Culture International and Cafe Culture China present: The Expanding Chinese Cafe Market Study Tour Shanghai Hotelex Coffee Expo Where: Shanghai New International Expo Centre, Pudong Di...
by Cafe Culture Mag

by Cafe Culture Mag



Get the most out of Christmas trade

In Australia and NZ, good weather combines with the festive season to make Christmas a busy time of year for most hospitality businesses. The silly season may bring a bit of extra stress, but by observing a few golden rules you...
by Cafe Culture Mag


Cybertongue technology!

A cybertongue that can rapidly detect lactose and spoilt milk, developed by CSIRO, has today been licensed to startup PPB Technology. The next-generation diagnostic tool uses biological sensors to detect substances like lactose...
by Cafe Culture Mag


An Interesting Christmas read.

Alternative Food Politics: From the Margins to the Mainstream covers topics ranging from ag-tech start-ups and social justice projects, to new ways of mediating food wastage, celebrity, and ‘ethical’ foods, as well as the r...
by Cafe Culture Mag